⚾ BaseChaser← Back to Odds

Cleveland Answers After Pittsburgh Takes Game 1

The Guardians avoided a costly sweep with a late comeback and a walk-off swing.

By BaseChaser · July 19, 2026 · 3 min read

The Pirates and Guardians split their July 18 doubleheader.

Pittsburgh controlled Game 1 with a 7-1 win. Jacob Gonzalez hit a two-run homer in the second inning, Esmerlyn Valdez added a two-run shot in the sixth, and Nick Gonzales also homered as the Pirates pulled away.

Cleveland answered in Game 2. The Guardians trailed 3-0 entering the eighth before RBI singles from Chase DeLauter and Kahlil Watson tied the game.

Travis Bazzana finished it in the ninth with a two-run walk-off homer, giving Cleveland a 5-3 win.

7-1
Pirates over Guardians in Game 1.
5-3
Guardians over Pirates in Game 2.
74.8%
Cleveland's latest BaseChaser playoff odds.

What It Means

The Guardians moved to 52-47. The Pirates ended the day at 51-48.

BaseChaser lists Cleveland at 74.8% to make the playoffs, down 1.3 percentage points. Pittsburgh sits at 30.0%, up 0.9 percentage points.

Pittsburgh picked up ground, but Cleveland avoided a costly sweep and stayed in a strong position on the BaseChaser board.

Track every team's playoff race with 100,000 simulations updated daily at BaseChaser.

100,000 simulations updated daily, see every team's playoff path

View MLB Playoff Odds →